By a Safety in Overtime

“I’ve always maintained that inbreeding should be practiced only through superior performing animals in an effort to filter out negative recessives. That’s why, despite a lack of evidence, I’ve half-heartedly clung to the notion that stakes-winning broodmares bearing the Rasmussen Factor might proved to be somewhat better producers.”

I received the comment above from Allison about six months ago on my post “You Learn Something New Every Day.” Per his request, I investigated stakes-winning mares bearing the Rasmussen Factor (RF) as producers. Let us start with prices.

Category                    Foals          Average          Maverage          Price Index

RF SW Dams              404           $64,521             202.22                   1.31

I identified 404 foals among sales foals of 2008-2111 whose dams were both stakes winners and possessed RF. Their prices were slightly above the norms, as you can see above, which was to be expected from stakes-winning mares. Their prices were slightly lower, however, than the prices for all 6,659 foals out of stakes-winning mares (average of $85,050, maverage of 222.66, Price Index of 1.45).

The chart below shows results for these 404 foals. APPPSW stands for average Performance Points per stakes winner, the benchmark now being 701.

Category                    Foals          SWs          %          APPPSW          PPI (Result)

RF SW Dams               404            20         4.95             780                    1.62

The RF group had very nice results, a PPI of 1.62, well above their price of 1.31, as demonstrated in the chart below.

Category                    Foals          Price Index          PPI (Result)          Difference

RF SW Dams              404                 1.31                       1.62                        +0.31

This appears to be a clear-cut victory for the RF group. But the 6,659 foals out of all stakes winners also had very similar prices and results, as summarized below.

All SW Dams             6,659               1.45                       1.74                        +0.29

The 404 foals had a difference of +0.31. All 6,659 foals out of stakes-winning dams had a difference of +0.29. The latter group had a price 0.14 higher than the former group (1.45 to 1.31). The latter group had a result 0.12 higher than the former group (1.74 to 1.62).

If this were a football game, the score would be 31-29 in favor of the RF group. They won by a safety in overtime.

So it does appear that stakes-winning dams with the RF factor were slightly better producers than all stakes-winning dams, but the emphasis has to be on the “slightly.”

Advertisements
This entry was posted in La Troienne and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s